Skip to content
Hugin
A dark adding machine on a desk with a long curl of blank paper tape spilling off the edge.
Public recordOpen fileEC0AD598

Public record case file · Latest recorded event Oct 16, 2026

Federal Improper Payments Oversight

Accountability file

A public-record case file for federal payment-integrity oversight, anchored on the Government Accountability Office's finding that agencies estimated about $186 billion in improper payments across 64 programs in fiscal year 2025. It keeps improper-payment estimates, modeled fraud-loss ranges, and adjudicated wrongdoing as distinct categories: an improper payment is an accounting and compliance measure — a payment that should not have been made or was made in the wrong amount, often from documentation or eligibility-verification gaps — and is not itself a finding of fraud or wrongdoing by any individual. No person is accused in this file.

Original editorial artwork generated for Hugin.

Latest recorded event
Oct 16, 2026
Source Anchors
32 verified
Timeline
26 events
Roles
7 public-record
Fingerprint
EC0A D598 8040
Saved reading0In this browser

Keep roles, events, and source records here to pick up later. Your list stays in this browser and can be lost if you clear site data. Copy your saved links to keep a backup in your notes.

Your reading list is empty. Use a save button on an event, source, or role dossier to add it here.

Start reading

26 events · 7 roles · 32 sources

Recent developments in the record

The latest dated events in this file. Open an event for its cited sources and evidence limits.

  1. GAO: IRS cannot say how many ghost preparers it has identified, investigated and addressed, and spreads the work across six offices with no strategy or goals →audit report · 1 source record
    Read summary and limits

    GAO reported on paid tax preparers who do not identify themselves on the returns they prepare, either leaving the paid-preparer section blank so the return looks self-prepared or using another preparer's identifiers. From 44 federal cases it reviewed covering 2017 through 2025 - 21 criminal and 23 civil - GAO describes schemes that inflated refunds, diverted refunds to the preparer's own account and stole taxpayers' identities, including manipulation of the Earned Income Tax Credit in both directions: fabricating circumstances to qualify a taxpayer, and inflating reported income into the range that produced a larger credit. Courts ordered restitution to IRS in 19 of the criminal cases totalling over $20 million, taxpayer restitution in three totalling almost $16,000, and in one case nearly $62,000 to the Iowa Workforce Development. GAO found that the systems IRS uses to track these cases and their outcomes are not connected and have limitations, so IRS does not know how many ghost preparers it has identified, investigated and addressed; that the work is fragmented across six offices with information-sharing opportunities missed; and that IRS has not set measurable objectives or performance goals for it. GAO made three recommendations - on data, on folding the effort into a comprehensive paid preparer strategy, and on measurable goals - and IRS agreed with all three, describing steps it plans to take or has started.

    Evidence limits. An oversight finding about IRS processes, not a finding against the agency, and not an improper-payment estimate: none of these figures belongs in this file's improper-payment totals. GAO says whether an act is fraud is for the adjudicative system to determine, and its 44 cases are a selection it assembled, not every such case - state prosecutions are out, undetected activity is out, and referred cases skew toward larger losses. Restitution is what courts ordered, not what was collected, and DOJ told GAO many defendants cannot repay. The statement that charged conduct is a fraction of the whole is IRS officials' view. No preparer or taxpayer is named here.

  2. GAO: only 10 of 18 major DOD IT business programs report assessing their fraud risks, and seven report staff without fraud-recognition training →oversight finding · 1 source record
    Read summary and limits

    GAO's annual review of 18 major DOD IT business programs, with $10.3 billion in planned fiscal 2024-2026 spending, found from April 2026 questionnaire responses that 10 programs reported assessing the fraud risks facing the program, five reported not assessing them and three did not know, and that seven reported staff unaware of or untrained in recognizing and reporting fraud in IT systems. DOD officials said the department requires only mandatory, general fraud-awareness training. GAO recommended that DOD's CIO, with the Comptroller, promote an anti-fraud tone in these programs through fraud-risk training, and reiterated six unimplemented recommendations from prior annual assessments.

    Evidence limits. A fraud-risk management control finding from self-reported questionnaires; GAO identifies no fraud or improper payment.

  3. CMS re-establishes its Do Not Pay match for Medicare providers and suppliers →records release · 1 source record
    Read summary and limits

    CMS published a Privacy Act notice re-establishing the Do Not Pay matching program it began in 2020 for Medicare providers and suppliers. Using enrollment data from PECOS, CMS will identify providers and suppliers ineligible for enrollment, suspend or revoke their billing privileges, recoup past payments, and avoid future improper payments. The program runs for an initial 36-month term, renewable for three years, and comments are due October 26.

    Evidence limits. A matching notice describes an eligibility check. It reports no improper-payment amount and makes no finding about any provider or supplier.

Read the full timeline →
Read the case scope: what is included and excluded

Included in this file

  • Government Accountability Office reports and explainers on federal improper payments, fraud-risk management, and the biennial High-Risk List (payment integrity).
  • The Office of Management and Budget's government-wide payment-integrity data as published on PaymentAccuracy.gov.
  • Agency-level and program-level improper-payment estimates as reported to and summarized by GAO (Medicare, Medicaid, EITC, SNAP, and the SBA Shuttered Venue Operators Grant program as the five largest drivers).
  • GAO recommendations and matters for congressional consideration, and their open-versus-implemented status.

Outside this file’s scope

  • Any characterization of an improper-payment estimate as adjudicated fraud, theft, or wrongdoing by a named agency, official, or recipient.
  • Per-program dollar allocations of the $186 billion sourced only to press summaries and not confirmed against the primary GAO record.
  • Partisan attribution of the reported totals to any administration; GAO's nonpartisan reporting is the neutral anchor.

What remains unresolved

These questions stay open in the case file.

  • What is the confirmed per-program dollar split of the $186 billion against the primary GAO record, beyond the five driver-program names and the ~73 percent concentration?
  • Beyond Public Law 119-77, which closed the Death Master File matter, and Public Law 119-21 section 90102, which GAO records as only partially addressing the analytics-center matter, how many of GAO's open recommendations and remaining March 2022 matters have agencies and Congress since implemented?
Read all 10 open questions →

Publishing limits

These are the standards every anchor on this file must clear.

Minimum source tier
  • official record
  • legislative record
  • oversight report
  • public record repository
Living people
For named officials or agencies, publish only source-backed public roles and exact record relationships; do not infer intent, blame, or wrongdoing from an accounting estimate.
Victim protection
Do not publish private or personal data; this file concerns agency- and program-level estimates, and no individual is accused.
Social leads
Coverage and commentary can start a lead, but published copy requires the primary GAO or OMB record, and an improper-payment estimate is never published as adjudicated fraud.

No guilt by proximity

An agency or program appearing in the same payment-integrity file is context only; a reported improper-payment rate does not imply fraud or misconduct by that agency, its officials, or any recipient.

Filed
Hugin · public social evidence reports
License
Text and data are shared under the terms noted at hugin.studio/support · attribution appreciated.
Fingerprint
EC0A D598 8040
For researchers & contributorsSource desk, research joins & machine-readable exportsEverything Hugin uses to grow and audit this file — connection detail, review posture, scout queue, and every export.
Connection map

How the public record is joined

Graph JSON
timeline backed26
source links33
role links25
open queues2
Source groups
15 sourcesoversight report15 linked recordsGAO-26-108694: Payment Integrity — Agencies' Estimated Improper Payments Increased to $186 Billion in Fiscal Year 2025 / GAO Blog: $186 Billion Was Lost to Improper Payments Last Year. How Can We Prevent Them In the Future? / GAO-26-109100: Combating Fraud — Managing Risks in Federally Funded, State-Administered Programs
9 sourcesofficial record9 linked recordsTreasury designation of OpenCorporates' U.S. legal entity dataset to the Do Not Pay Working System (FR Doc 2026-16800) / DOL Privacy Act notice establishing a Do Not Pay matching program (FR Doc 2026-17838, 91 FR 56223) / HHS Privacy Act notice establishing a Do Not Pay matching program (FR Doc 2026-17907, 91 FR 56457)
Timeline joins
Mar 17, 2022 / officialGAO issues matters for congressional consideration on reducing improper payments2 linked recordsAn open matter for congressional consideration is a recommendation status, not a finding against any agency or person.
Mar 29, 2023 / officialGAO reports the fiscal year 2022 improper-payment estimate1 linked recordThe $247 billion figure is an agency-reported improper-payment estimate over a subset of programs, not a fraud finding or a count of adjudicated losses.
Role joins
audit authorityU.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO)10 linked recordsGAO reports estimate and audit; they do not adjudicate fraud or assign wrongdoing to any individual.
official record holderU.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS)2 linked recordsBeing the subject of a GAO recommendation is an oversight finding about agency processes, not a finding of wrongdoing by the agency, any employee, any preparer or any taxpayer.

Connections are navigation aids. They show where a record, event, or role is sourced; they do not convert association, correspondence, testimony requests, or document appearance into misconduct findings.

verified anchors32
timeline events26
research queues2
No hand-tuned source desk on this case yet, so no lead or probe queue is counted for it.
scout targets16
first-pass scout14
credential queue2
connectors16
keyless APIs6
free-key targets2
public search8
official pages0
POST templates0
CourtListener Search API / keyless apiGDELT DOC API / keyless apiFederal Register API / keyless apiGovInfo public document search / public searchRegulations.gov public search / public searcheCFR public search / public searchDOJ News API / keyless apiFOIA.gov government website search / public searchFBI Vault search / public searchNational Archives Catalog API / free key requiredData.gov CKAN catalog API / free key requiredCongress.gov public search / public search

Default public-record source desk for cases without a hand-tuned scout profile.

Source lanespublic-record-discovery
Sharing stateautomatic sharing disabled
Next actionAdd source receipts to the review queue before promoting case claims or social copy.
keyless apiCourtListener Search APIpublic-record source deltasLegal search across opinions, dockets, RECAP data, judges, and arguments.
keyless apiGDELT DOC APIpublic-record source deltasCoverage-index discovery for fresh public reporting rows.
keyless apiFederal Register APIpublic-record source deltasOfficial rule, notice, and agency-document discovery.
public searchGovInfo public document searchpublic-record source deltasFree public search across official publications from all three branches of the U.S. federal government.
public-record source deltas

Source leads and automated probes are review inventory. They become verified anchors only after Hugin can attach the public record, legal posture, and no-allegation guardrails.

Join board

Public-record joins are wired into exports

These are not loose TODOs anymore. Each lane below is computed from the case file's source tiers, then joined to matching sources, timeline events, role nodes, and release-roadmap requests.

wired lanes0
review lanes2
source joins30
release joins0
Needs review2Sources have landed but the lane is not promoted to wired yet.
Needs reviewGAO recommendation and matters tracking
15 sources

Track the status of GAO's three fiscal year 2025 recommendations and the nine March 2022 matters that remained open as of April 2026 — one having been closed by Public Law 119-77 and one only partially addressed by Public Law 119-21 section 90102 — as agencies and Congress act.

timeline15
roles5
release asks0
Connected roles
U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO)U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS)U.S. Office of Management and Budget (OMB)
Release requests
No release request is attached to this lane yet.
PublishesOpen-versus-implemented status with the GAO record that reports each change.
BlockedAssertions that a recommendation was met without a GAO or official record confirming it.
Needs reviewPer-program dollar-split verification
15 sources

Verify the Medicare / Medicaid / EITC / SNAP / Shuttered Venue Operators Grant dollar allocations of the $186 billion against the full GAO-26-108694 record before publishing any per-program figure.

timeline15
roles5
release asks0
Connected roles
U.S. Government Accountability Office (GAO)U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS)U.S. Office of Management and Budget (OMB)
Release requests
No release request is attached to this lane yet.
PublishesGAO-confirmed program names, the ~73 percent concentration, and any dollar figures explicitly stated in the primary GAO record.
BlockedPer-program dollar allocations sourced only to press summaries, presented as GAO-confirmed.
Public utility

Help grow the source queue

Hugin accepts public records, not accusations. A submitted URL lands in a review lane, gets source-validated, and only becomes a case anchor after the evidence rules and privacy gates are satisfied.

Review posture

What this case can prove right now

Fact-check desk
publishable claims24
source repair0
known anchors32
lead quarantine0
scout targets16
first-pass scout14
credential queue2
scout connectors16
rankmedium126 priority score
readyReady for first-pass public review24 publishable claim rows / 32 source anchors / 14 first-pass source rows
actions6 start-here rows9 total workbench action rows
blockers1 launch checks2 source-scout rows require free operator keys

Fact-check status is a review posture, not a verdict. Source-scout rows are leads until a reviewer joins them to publishable anchors; claim-ledger rows are timeline-derived and still require source validation plus no-allegation guardrails before promotion.

Source intake

Queue a public record

Public queue

Paste an official or public-record URL. Hugin classifies the lane first, keeps lead-only material quarantined, and requires source validation before anything reaches the case file.

Use an official or public-record page. Local, private, leaked, or credentialed URLs are rejected.
Queue a public source for review.
Visible queue

Latest submitted public URLs

Sanitized queue view: Hugin shows the public URL, lane, status, and why a source has not been promoted. Submitter identifiers are not shown.

Public queue loaded.Live queue connectedQueue hash ae382727cbe6
No public submissions in this snapshot.When someone submits a source, this board will show the URL, lane, status, hold reason, and next review step before anything can become part of the case file.
known sources32
publishable anchors27
atlas sources27
keyless feeds23
release asks7
document jobs32
privacy triage3
lead quarantine0
01Submit URLPublic URL, label, and context enter the source queue.
02Classify laneOfficial, court, legislative, civil, state, repository, or lead quarantine.
03Validate sourcePublisher, date, scope, privacy, and duplicate checks run before promotion.
04Promote anchorOnly source-backed, privacy-cleared records can join timeline or role surfaces.
Contribution guide

Submit sources, not claims

A source is a public URL someone else can inspect. A claim is an interpretation. Hugin queues sources first and keeps claims out until a reviewed public record supports the exact wording.

Accepted

Official agency pages, court dockets, congressional releases, civil records, state updates, and public repositories with source URLs.

Publisher, date, record family, and why the URL belongs in this file.

Source URLs first. Context is welcome, but claims do not publish from submissions alone.

Not accepted

Private tips, survivor identifiers, sealed or leaked material, graphic details, and private contact data.

Screenshots or social posts without a public source URL.

Misconduct labels for living people unless the exact cited public record supports that exact statement.

What changed

Case change ledger

Audit feed for source anchors, queue decisions, privacy-review jobs, and hashes. It explains the process without turning leads into claims.

Change ledger loaded.Ledger hash ae0eaebc28c3Case hash ec0ad5988040
Oct 16, 2026source added

GAO-27-108176 — Tax Filing: IRS Should Enhance Ghost Preparer Identification and Compliance Efforts in a Comprehensive Preparer Strategy

Status
source anchor in case file
Evidence state
case anchor
Lane
oversight report

An oversight report, not an improper-payment estimate and not a tally of adjudicated fraud: GAO states that 'whether an act is in fact fraud is a determination to be made through the judicial or other adjudicative system', and the 44 cases are a selection GAO assembled rather than all such cases - it did not attempt to identify every federal criminal and civil case, state prosecutions are excluded, and GAO notes referred cases skew toward larger losses. The restitution figures are amounts courts ordered, not amounts collected, and DOJ told GAO many defendants lack the assets to repay. The statement that charged conduct is a fraction of overall ghost preparer fraud is attributed in the report to IRS officials. No dollar figure here can be added to this file's improper-payment totals, and no preparer, taxpayer or firm is named by this desk. Read from the report PDF and highlights; the appendix I case list was not checked against the underlying court dockets.

Next: Keep source-linked timeline and role claims limited to the extracted facts.a1aa31acdfe7
Sep 28, 2026source added

IT Systems Annual Assessment: DOD Should Improve IT Fraud Risk Management Practices (GAO-26-108596)

Status
source anchor in case file
Evidence state
case anchor
Lane
oversight report

A fraud-risk management finding drawn from program questionnaire responses; it identifies no fraud, loss or improper payment in any program.

Next: Keep source-linked timeline and role claims limited to the extracted facts.002eac49ea39
Safety posture

Locked to public records and bounded intake

Post throttleSource intake is DB-rate-limited to 6 submissions per minute per network key before a record is written.
Public URL onlyLocalhost, private networks, URL credentials, unsupported protocols, malformed URLs, and overlong fields are rejected.
No paid callsThe data export links render deterministic public-record payloads. They do not call LLMs or paid upstream APIs.
Identity minimizedSubmitter material is converted to a server-side HMAC hash, and the public queue does not return raw IPs or user agents.