Skip to content
Hugin
A worker walks beside tanks and pipes at an industrial facility near a river.

Hugin News

GAO cites recurring transparency gaps in FEMA preparedness grant decisions

2 min read

Original editorial artwork from the Hugin archive; symbolic illustration, not a depiction of the subject.

This record was prepared on the date shown and recovered after a publishing interruption.

The Government Accountability Office says applicants for some FEMA preparedness grants have lacked clear scoring and risk-model information. Its November 12 report brings together earlier findings on grant administration and describes funding disruptions and litigation over grant conditions. The cited findings span several years and do not establish that every current award has the same defects.

femadisaster-preparednessfederal-grantsoversighttransparency
source receipt
1
source host
1
read time
2min
primary source
Linked

Federal emergency preparedness grant applicants have not always received clear information about how their applications are scored or how certain risk models work, the Government Accountability Office says. Its November 12 report summarizes recurring findings from earlier reviews of the Federal Emergency Management Agency's grant programs.

The grants support equipment, training, planning and other activities to help communities prepare for terrorism and disasters. GAO says FEMA has 13 preparedness grants totaling $2.9 billion for fiscal year 2026.

What applicants were told

In a July 2023 report, GAO found that FEMA's 2021 transit security funding notice did not accurately describe how key aspects of project merit, including risk reduction, would be scored. FEMA also did not consistently award grants to the highest-scoring applications as the notice outlined, GAO says.

In a separate September 2025 report, GAO found that a port security grant announcement did not describe all evaluation criteria or how criteria were weighted in an overall project score. The agency concluded applicants might lack information needed to choose projects likely to score highly.

GAO also describes earlier concerns about changes to national priority areas and the information in risk models. For example, it says a transit security risk model did not include cyber threats that the Department of Homeland Security had identified as relevant in fiscal year 2019. These findings relate to the specific programs and periods GAO reviewed; they do not prove every current grant decision has the same problem.

Funding and court cases

GAO says DHS terminated grants and paused funding in 2025, delaying preparedness grant disbursements. A federal district court required FEMA to stop delaying disbursements while that case proceeds, the report says.

DHS also imposed immigration-enforcement cooperation conditions. GAO says a district court prohibited enforcement of the 2025 conditions, while similar conditions were attached to 2026 awards. Lawsuits about the conditions remained ongoing as of November 2026, according to the report. GAO calls on FEMA to address open recommendations on evaluation criteria, risk models and lessons from prior grant actions.

Source links