The Environmental Protection Agency says 24 industry-submitted studies considered in its draft risk evaluation of the fragrance chemical HHCB were unavailable to the public during its earlier comment period. A notice published November 16 invites comments on the newly available supporting materials by December 16, 2026.
What the public could not access
EPA says it became aware during the April 14–June 15, 2026, comment period of an inadvertent administrative issue in its Health and Environmental Research Online system, known as HERO. The issue made the studies unavailable to the public even though they had been considered in the draft evaluation.
The agency says the issue was resolved and the studies became publicly available in HERO on October 14. Its notice identifies an HHCB Data Availability Memorandum in docket EPA-HQ-OPPT-2018-0430 as the list of those studies.
The notice establishes EPA's acknowledgment of the access gap and its renewed invitation for scrutiny. It does not independently establish the studies' quality or how they affect the draft conclusions.
Why the evaluation matters
EPA describes HHCB as a synthetic musk widely used in fragrances, including household detergents, cleaners and air fresheners. It says workers may be exposed through dust, mist or vapor when making or using these products, and consumers during intended product use. Environmental releases occur primarily when fragrance products are disposed of down drains, entering wastewater, according to the notice.
These are the agency's descriptions of possible exposure pathways, not a finding in this report that a particular product or exposure has caused harm. The notice says EPA will consider comments while finalizing its evaluation. Any determination of unreasonable risk and any resulting risk-management action remain distinct steps.
How to scrutinize the record
EPA seeks feedback on the newly available studies in the context of the draft evaluation. The printed deadline is December 16. The notice directs readers to the docket on Regulations.gov and warns against submitting confidential business information through that website or email.
A specific contribution to public scrutiny would be a source-linked assessment from a knowledgeable reader explaining whether, and how, these newly accessible studies change the draft evaluation's conclusions. No such assessment is established here, and this request does not imply that one has been completed, required or withheld.

