The Justice Department says its proposed antitrust judgment with Willow Bridge Property Company does not need independent technical testing or an annual public compliance report. In a response published Monday, it rejected requests to add those safeguards before asking a court to approve the deal.
What the comments challenged
DOJ received two public comments on the proposed judgment in its RealPage rental-pricing case. One asked whether the restrictions would reach renewal prices as well as prices for new tenants, and sought notice to renters when automated pricing influenced a renewal offer. DOJ replied that the proposed limits on the use and sharing of competitors' nonpublic data apply to recommendations for both kinds of leases. It said automated revenue-management software alone is not the conduct alleged in its complaint and that a separate tenant-notice or human-review requirement would go beyond that case.
The other commenter sought independent technical verification of pricing products, a larger internal audit sample and public compliance reporting. DOJ said the proposed judgment requires third-party revenue-management providers to certify compliance and gives the government rights to inspect Willow Bridge's proprietary code and records. It called the proposed annual audit, including at least 12 randomly selected local, regional or supervisory employees who manage property operations, sufficient. DOJ said public reporting could reveal competitively sensitive information and create a risk of coordination among competing landlords.
What the proposal would cover
According to DOJ's response, the complaint alleges that Willow Bridge shared confidential leasing data with RealPage and aligned pricing through its software. These are allegations, not adjudicated findings. The proposed judgment would bar specified uses of competitors' nonpublic information and certain revenue-management products, require antitrust compliance measures, and allow government inspections. DOJ said the proposal concerns its claims against Willow Bridge; it would not resolve claims against other defendants or other plaintiffs' claims.
DOJ says it will move for entry after publication of the comments and response. The court must decide whether entry is in the public interest. The response records the department's position; it does not say the court has approved the judgment or that the alleged conduct has been proved.
A later public court order would establish whether the proposed judgment was entered, rejected or modified. Readers with that docket record, or a concrete method for independently checking compliance without exposing competitors' data, are invited to share it for review.

