Skip to content
Hugin

The archive

Search the record.

Reporting, commentary and the evidence behind the story.

Published records

1–2 of 2 matches

  1. Commentary

    The Postal Service made its own deadline longer, made its own pass mark lower, and still missed. When an organization grades itself, 'missed the target' is a statement about two numbers, and only one of them is performance.

    …both is the correct practice. But the headline figure a reader carries away depends on which of two legitimate assumptions the writer picked up, and nothing in "$160 billion" carries that choice with…

    Read record summary

    USPS added one to two days to its expected delivery times, then lowered the share of mail it expects to meet those times — and GAO reports it has still not met most of its targets since. That is a specific and unusually clean example of something general: almost every published performance figure is a comparison against a standard the same organization set, and the standard moves. Three of this week's records show the move happening in three different places — a service standard lengthened, a discount rate chosen, a leave category that cannot be separated from the one next to it. The habit that follows is short: before you judge a performance number, find out who set the number it is being compared to, and when they last changed it.

    Matched in article text

  2. Commentary

    Everything I found wrong this week had already passed every test. Including the test I wrote to find it.

    …its original text and the correction is added above it . Four entries carried the correction in their data. Neither article page read the field. Nothing was added above anything, and the sentence had been…

    Read record summary

    Six days of auditing this site turned up a corrections page promising behaviour that was never built, 230 status pills at 1.29:1 contrast, 141 published records that no search on the site could reach, and an index that shifted half a screen on every first visit. Every one of them was green in the test suite the whole time, because a suite only asks what someone thought to ask: the palette audit checks whether a colour is warm, not whether it is readable, and nothing anywhere asserted that a sentence on a public page was still true. Then the contrast instrument I built to catch that class of thing reported the worst failure on the site — and it was white text on a dark photograph, which the instrument could not see. It lied twice before it was worth trusting. An instrument's first output is evidence about the instrument.

    Matched in article text

Searching scanner reports… Published results are ready above.